Ask ChatGPT, “Who’s a good plumber in Cheektowaga?” and you won’t get ten blue links. You’ll get a few business names, a short reason for each, and sometimes a link.
The question for every small business owner in Western New York is simple: is your business one of those names?
This isn’t a future trend anymore. In BrightLocal’s 2026 survey of 1,002 U.S. adults, 45% said they had used AI tools like ChatGPT to find local business recommendations, up from 6% the year before. That made AI the third most common source of recommendations, behind Google and Facebook. (BrightLocal)
People still check. The same research found 88% fact-check the reviews AI tools cite. So AI often starts the search, and your website, reviews, and listings still have to back it up.
Take five minutes and ask ChatGPT (or Google’s AI answers) a few questions your customers would ask:
Write down who shows up. Are you there? Are your competitors? Is the information about you correct? Answers can change from one search to the next, so try a few times.
If you aren’t showing up, or the details are wrong, keep reading.
OpenAI has not published exactly how ChatGPT picks local businesses. (WebFX) What we do know is that these tools search the web and pull from sources they can read and trust.
In one BrightLocal study of 800 local searches, business websites made up 58% of the sources ChatGPT showed. Mentions of businesses on other sites made up 27%, and directories made up 15%. (BrightLocal)
In plain English: your own website matters most. What other people say about you comes next.
The good news is that most of this is the same work that helps you on Google. This is what we call Answer Engine Optimization, or AEO.
No one can guarantee that ChatGPT or any AI tool will recommend your business. These systems change often, and answers vary from search to search. Anyone who promises a guaranteed spot is guessing.
What you can control is how clear, consistent, and trustworthy your business looks online. That helps with AI, Google, and the customer who lands on your site.
Big national chains have marketing departments working on this. Most small businesses in Buffalo and WNY don’t.
That is the gap we want to help close. When people in our community ask AI for a recommendation, the local roofer, the family-owned bakery, or the neighborhood tutoring center deserves a fair shot at being named. Keeping that business local keeps money in Western New York.
We can check how your business shows up in AI search and Google, find what is missing or wrong, and give you a clear list of what to fix first. We are a local team working with small and mid-sized businesses, startups, and nonprofits across WNY.
FAQs
What is AEO? Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) means setting up your website and online presence so AI tools and search engines can understand your business and use it in their answers.
Is AEO different from SEO? They overlap a lot. SEO focuses on ranking in search results. AEO focuses on being clear enough to be quoted or recommended in AI answers. Good service pages, FAQs, and consistent business info help both.
Can I pay to be recommended by ChatGPT? Not in the regular recommendations. What you can do is make sure your website, listings, and reviews give AI tools accurate, trustworthy information to work with.
How long does it take to show up in AI search? There is no set timeline. It depends on your competition, how clear your website is, and how consistent your information is online. Results vary because these tools change often.
Does my small business really need to worry about this? If your customers search for services like yours, it is worth checking. Run the five-minute test above and see where you stand.
We can help your business get better discoverability on AI platforms like Chat GPT, Claude, and more. Contact us today and let's have a chat about your digital marketing strategy.
Schedule A Meeting
Hoss Digital, Inc. offers a full suite of digital marketing services to compliment your website, grow your brand, and amplify your lead generation process.
© Copyright 2026 All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions